• Covid-19
  • Travel Protocols
  • Immigration & Customs Form
Friday, May 30, 2025
SKNIS
  • Home
  • About
  • Press Releases
  • Parliament
  • In The News
  • Bills
No Result
View All Result
SKNIS
No Result
View All Result
Home Featured

CCJ Quashes Decision by Parole Board to Revoke Parole of Sears

SKNISEditor by SKNISEditor
May 20, 2022
in Featured, Press Releases
CCJ Quashes Decision by Parole Board to Revoke Parole of Sears
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Related posts

Saint Kitts and Nevis Accedes to Key Inter-American Conventions on Rights of Persons with Disabilities and Older Persons

Saint Kitts and Nevis Accedes to Key Inter-American Conventions on Rights of Persons with Disabilities and Older Persons

May 29, 2025
EU Eyes Regional Green Hydrogen Market —Saint Kitts and Nevis Potential Hub

Nearly EC $25M in Direct Payments to Key Public Institutions Secured Following Christophe Harbour Sale

May 29, 2025

Port of Spain, Trinidad and Tobago. The Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) today quashed the decision of the Parole Board to revoke the parole of Mr Hillaire Sears, presently incarcerated at the Belize Central Prison and issued consequential orders against the Parole Board, Minister of National Security and the Attorney General of Belize for breach of Mr Sears’ constitutional rights but did not order damages sought by Mr Sears. Mr Sears was first incarcerated on 21 March 2001 on a charge of murder, for which he was convicted in December 2002. On appeal, a conviction for manslaughter was substituted and he was sentenced to twenty-five (25) years’ imprisonment. He was granted parole and released on 21 December 2012. On 3 April 2014, while working at the prison, Mr Sears was suspected of violating one of the conditions of his parole, specifically that he would not indulge ‘in the illegal use, sale, possession, distribution, transportation or be in the presence of controlled drugs.’ Mr Sears was subjected to a urine test and detained that night. He remained detained for fifty-five (55) days before, on 28 May 2014, the Parole Board issued a decision informing him that the urine analysis confirmed that he had tested positive for cannabis and that his parole had been revoked.  Mr Sears was never afforded an opportunity to be heard by the Parole Board. Four (4) years later, he brought a constitutional claim seeking declaratory relief that his rights to personal liberty, due process, equal protection of the law and against inhuman and degrading punishment, had been breached. He also sought an order that he be released from prison and also be granted damages, vindicatory damages and costs. The Supreme Court dismissed his claim, holding that a constitutional claim was not the correct procedure to approach the court since his substantive case called for judicial review of the Parole Board’s decision and a quashing of that decision. Further, the Parole Board had clear proof of his parole violation and was legally empowered under the Prison Rules to revoke his parole. The Court also dismissed the notion of a mandatory requirement for an oral hearing being granted to parolees before the revocation of their parole. The Court of Appeal agreed with the Supreme Court that since the substantive relief sought by Mr Sears amounted to a quashing of the Parole Board’s decision, his action was brought via the wrong procedure. Today, the CCJ allowed Mr Sears’ appeal and set aside the judgment of the Court of Appeal. The Court issued declarations that the manner in which Mr Sears was re-incarcerated breached his constitutional right to personal liberty guaranteed under section 5 of the Constitution and that the Parole Board’s revocation of his parole breached his constitutional right to personal liberty and equal protection of the law as guaranteed by sections 5 and 6 of the Constitution. Importantly, the CCJ quashed the Parole Board’s order which revoked Mr Sears’ parole and ordered that he be released from prison forthwith. Costs were awarded to Mr Sears for the proceedings before the CCJ, as agreed by the parties. The matter was heard by the Honourable Mr Justice Adrian Saunders, President and the Honourable Justices Jacob Wit, Winston Anderson, Maureen Rajnauth-Lee and Andrew Burgess. Ms Leslie Mendez and Hector Guerra appeared for the Appellant. Ms Samantha Matute-Tucker, Assistant Solicitor General appeared for the Respondents. Full reasons for the decision are to be given in due course. 

Previous Post

WORLD METROLOGY DAY – 20 May 2022 Metrology in the Digital Era

Next Post

The Government of Guyana and FAO sign Country Programme Framework and MOR for
hosting LARC 38

Next Post
The Government of Guyana and FAO sign Country Programme Framework and MOR forhosting LARC 38

The Government of Guyana and FAO sign Country Programme Framework and MOR for
hosting LARC 38

WHAT'S HOT

Saint Kitts and Nevis Accedes to Key Inter-American Conventions on Rights of Persons with Disabilities and Older Persons

Saint Kitts and Nevis Accedes to Key Inter-American Conventions on Rights of Persons with Disabilities and Older Persons

May 29, 2025
EU Eyes Regional Green Hydrogen Market —Saint Kitts and Nevis Potential Hub

Nearly EC $25M in Direct Payments to Key Public Institutions Secured Following Christophe Harbour Sale

May 29, 2025
Prime Minister Drew Reinforces Bold Commitments to Strengthening the Nursing Fraternity and Regional Leadership in Healthcare

Official Statement by Prime Minister Hon. Dr. Terrance Drew outlining the significance of the Christophe Harbour sale to Safe Harbor Marinas, LLC

May 29, 2025

BROWSE BY CATEGORIES

  • 2025
  • Attorney General, Ministry of Justice and Legal Affairs
  • Bills
  • Featured
  • Featured Ministry
  • Government Projects
  • Home Page Slider
  • In Focus
  • In The News
  • Interviews
  • Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Marine Resources; Cooperatives; Entrepreneurship and Creative Economy
  • Ministry of Education, Youth; Social Development; Gender Affairs; Aging and Disabilities
  • Ministry of Foreign Affairs, International Trade, Industry and Commerce and Consumer Affairs; Economic Development and Investment
  • Ministry of Public Infrastructure, Energy and Utilities; Domestic Transport; Information, Communication and Technology; and Posts
  • Ministry of Sustainable Development, Environment; Climate Action and Constituency Empowerment
  • Ministry of Tourism, Civil Aviation; International Transport; Employment and Labour; Urban Development
  • Notices
  • Parliament
  • PMO Press Releases
  • Press Conferences
  • Press Releases
  • Prime Ministers Office, Ministry of Finance; National Security; Citizenship and Immigration; Health and Social Security
  • Register of Voters
  • Round Table
  • The Cabinet Secretariat, Cabinet Secteatry
  • Uncategorized

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK

Facebook Pagelike Widget

LOCATION

St. Kitts Nevis Information Service
Government Headquarters
Chruch Street
Basseterre
St. Kitts
Tel:(869)467-1416

FOLLOW US

  • Government of St. Kitts & Nevis

© 2020 St. Kitts & Nevis Information Service. Developed by E-Government Unit

No Result
View All Result
  • Home

© 2020 St. Kitts & Nevis Information Service. Developed by E-Government Unit